It was really good: We killed Attumen, Moroes, Maiden and the Opera (big bad wolf) on our first attempts. We did 2 or 3 attempts on Nightbane and then moved on to Curator. Finally got him on the 4th attempt. After the Opera event one of the healers asked, "Is this really your guild's first attempt?"
Congratulations to the loot winners:
Arvernien, Detrimental, Lassyran, and Dpre.
Some of us managed to get back into our saved Karazhan with PUG people rounding out the group. We had 4 paladins and it was short and chaotic. We managed to kill Terestian Illhoof - grats to Detrimental for successfully warlock tanking the imps. Illhoof dropped junk. We attempted Shade of Aran and wiped at 17%. The group broke up after that.